By Sarwan Nasar
The National Finance Commission (NFC) Award is a constitutional mechanism in Pakistan that describes how national tax revenues are divided between the federal government and the four provinces. It is established under Article 160 of the 1973 Constitution to ensure equitable resource distribution and provincial financial autonomy. Article 160 of the Constitution of Islamic Republic of Pakistan authorizes the President of Pakistan to approve distribution of revenues between the federation and the provinces through an Order, called the NFC Award, on the recommendation of the National Finance Commission (NFC). Clause 3(B) of Article 160 of the Constitution of Islamic Republic of Pakistan explains that Federal Finance Minister and Provincial Finance Ministers shall monitor the implementation of the Award biannually and lay their report before both Houses of Majalis-e-Shoora (Parliament) and the Provincial Assemblies.
According to the working papers written by Usman Mustafa, published in 2011 by Pakistan Institute of Development economics (PIDE), the first award was presented by Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto government in 1974. Resources were vertically distributed at a fixed ratio of 20:80 among federal and provincial governments and criteria used for resource redistribution was recommended to be population. In the said award Punjab got huge share of 60.25%, while other provinces suffered. Sind share was 22.50%, Khyber Pashtunkhwa 13.39% and Balochistan was given only 3.86%. Same formula was applied in 1979 award. In 1996 and 2006 awards, share of provinces in divisible pool was in ratio of 62.5:37.5 and 45:55 respectively. Among the provinces or in horizontal distribution, population was kept constant as the only indicator for provinces share.
Purpose of the NFC Award is to: (1) Review the collection of revenues by the Centre from provinces. (2) Redistribute vertically between the federal and the provincial governments, as well as horizontally among the provinces. (3) Smooth and equitable fiscal transfers from Centre to provinces that may lead to the development and prosperity of all federating units. Historically, allocations were based solely on population indicator. However, the historic 7th NFC Award, officially signed in Gwadar on 30th December 2009 (implemented in 2010), broadened the criteria to address regional inequalities. Among the provinces, the formula is currently weighted using these factors: Population 82 %, Poverty and Backwardness 10.3 %, Inverse Population Density (large area and scattered population) 2.7 % and collection of Revenue (Revenue generation and collection by provinces) 05 %. While, share of provinces from divisible pool is in ratio of 44:56 as per 2009 NFC Award and now is 42.5:57.5 as is recommended in the said NFC award.
In the 7th NFC Award, addition of three more indicators in horizontal distribution benefitted Balochistan. As compared to 1974, 1979, 1990 and 2006 awards, Balochistan share was increased upto 9.09% in 7th NFC Award of 2009. The said award factored in 10.3% weightage for poverty and backwardness and 2.7% for inverse population density. This specifically favored Balochistan due to its large landmass and scattered population. On the other hand, application or utilization of this share on provincial level is not actually benefitting the general people of the province. According to a case study of Balochistan, titled “Pakistan NFC Award 2009 and People’s Perceptions”, prepared by Musarrat Karamat Ali and Dr. Amanat Ali Jalbani, Balochistan’s social set up is predominantly tribal in nature compare to other provinces. The ineffective land reforms and traditional tribal lords control the lives of common people in Balochistan. General perception is that these lords suppress common people and obstruct developmental activities in the region which includes establishment of educational institutions, infrastructure, health facilities, provision of clean water, exploration of new well heads and mineral resources. They receive funds/packages from the federal government which did not have any trickle down effects on masses.
Dr. Nadeem Javaid, vice chancellor of PIDE, have written an Essay in the “Discourse”, Quarterly Magazine of July to September 2025. He argues that 18th Amendment delivered historic autonomy. But autonomy without responsibility is dangerous. More than a decade later, provinces still raise less than 1% of their GDP in taxes. The services sector contributes over 57% of GDP, yet provinces collect less than 0.5% in tax revenue from it. Agriculture income tax and property taxes remain grossly underutilized. Worse, provinces themselves deny Provincial Finance Commission (PFC) Awards, leaving districts and local governments dependent on provincial handouts. This double centralization—provinces leaning on the Centre, districts leaning on provinces—creates a distorted fiscal pyramid where accountability is weakest at the grassroots. The result? Provinces enjoy political space to spend but not the responsibility to raise. Citizens are left with weak schools, hospitals, and municipal services, while the Centre borrows heavily, squeezing out investment in national projects.
The Constitution mandates the NFC to be formed every 5 years and a fresh Award to be enacted. However, it is now a decade and a half since the NFC Award of 2010 and three Commissions – 8th, 9th and 10th – have lapsed without result. There are voices for changes and a debate is under way; with the Centre and provinces positioning themselves at different points. Moreover, International organizations like the IMF (International Monetary Fund), World Bank, and UNDP recommend reforming Pakistan’s National Finance Commission (NFC) award by reducing the reliance on population size and integrating indicators for poverty, revenue generation, and human development. The World Bank and UNDP recommend incorporating additional indicators, such as (1) Human Development Index (HDI) metrics, including health and education outcomes, (2) Environmental sustainability (e.g., forest cover and carbon offsets) and (3) Gender equity (female labor force participation). International organizations stress that true fiscal equity requires transferring revenue-sharing frameworks down from the provincial level to local governments. Experts from the UNDP and research bodies like the PIDE (Pakistan Institute of Development Economics) also recommend establishing a permanent, technically competent NFC Secretariat rather than forming temporary, politically driven commissions.



1 Comment
Pingback: Modern Skills, Self-Employment Key to Empowering Youth: Nosherwani - Daily 6AM