Committee raises serious concerns over performance of Rs15bn-plus programme; orders physical verification, DC-level scrutiny of plantation spending and nurseries, reviews audit observation of alleged Rs55.420m loss
QUETTA (6 AM Report): The Balochistan Public Accounts Committee (PAC) has raised serious concerns over the performance of the Rs15 billion-plus Ten Billion Tree Tsunami Programme after Rs6.35 billion in expenditure, warning that the matter could be referred to the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) if its directives are not implemented.
The committee, chaired by Asghar Ali Tareen, reviewed various paras of the 2022-23 special audit report concerning the programmes Forestry and Wildlife components for 2019-22.
According to an audit para, the project recorded 12.43 per cent physical and 10 per cent financial progress during its first three years. Audit attributed the slow progress partly to frequent transfers of officers in Project Implementation Units and delays in filling key posts in the Project Management Unit.
The PAC also expressed concern that the special audit report had yet to reach the committee and directed the department to facilitate completion of physical verification and satisfy audit authorities within 20 days.
PAC Reviews Audit Observation of Alleged Rs55.420m Loss
The committee reviewed an audit observation concerning an alleged financial loss of Rs55.420 million linked to incomplete nursery infrastructure targets. Audit said 70 nursery sites were to be established, developed or upgraded, but required infrastructure had not been completed at various PIUs.
The PAC sought details of the total number of nurseries, those completed and those handed over to relevant departments.
It also reviewed an audit para concerning Rs1,236.719 million spent on procurement of plants and plantation activities. According to audit, required consultation through District Coordination Committees over selection of plantation sites had not taken place in various areas.
The committee directed that expenditure, plantation sites, records and physical results be further verified through the concerned Deputy Commissioners.
GIS/FMIS Monitoring System Examined by PAC
An audit observation concerning the effective establishment of the GIS/FMIS system, intended for real-time monitoring of project activities and progress, was also examined.
PAC Chairman Asghar Ali Tareen expressed displeasure over delays and gave the department another 15 days to provide the required records, replies and reports and satisfy audit authorities. He said action under relevant rules would follow if responsibility was established against any official.
Some audit paras concerning the Forest and Wildlife Department were settled after the required records and explanations were provided, while further action was ordered on pending matters.
PAC member Obaidullah Gorgage said the ground situation and transparency of nurseries would be verified through the concerned Deputy Commissioners or Commissioners, warning that failure to comply with PAC directives could result in the matter being referred to NAB for action.
Tareen said unnecessary delays and repeated extensions would no longer be tolerated and directed all concerned authorities to provide records and reports within the stipulated period to ensure transparent scrutiny of public funds and project performance.


