PAC expresses serious concern over multi-million-rupee audit objections at Sandeman Provincial Hospital; Rs30.016m medicine procurement and Rs22.825m drug stock audit paras examined, matter to be raised in Assembly and brought to Chief Secretary’s notice
QUETTA (6 AM Report): Balochistan Assembly Public Accounts Committee (PAC) Chairman Asghar Ali Tareen has directed the Health Department to submit all records, explanations and supporting documents relating to audit objections at Sandeman Provincial Hospital Quetta within 15 days, warning that the committee could consider recommending referral of the matter to the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) or registration of an FIR if the response remained unsatisfactory.
Tareen said the Health Department had been given repeated opportunities over the past one-and-a-half years to provide the required record and explanations concerning the audit paras, but satisfactory progress had yet to be made.
“The PAC’s time and authority should not be taken lightly,” he said, directing the department to comply with the committee’s instructions in accordance with the relevant rules and procedures.
PAC Examines Special Audit of Sandeman Provincial Hospital
The PAC meeting, chaired by Tareen at the Balochistan Assembly committee room, examined various paras of the Special Audit 2022-23 of Sandeman Provincial Hospital Quetta.
The committee was informed that out of Rs10.443 billion available to the hospital from fiscal years 2017-18 to 2021-22, Rs9.576 billion had been spent. The chairman and committee members expressed serious concern over the failure to provide certain accounts and supporting records sought by the committee.
The PAC examined an audit para concerning the procurement of medicines worth Rs30.016 million.
According to the special audit, a supply order was issued in the name of M/s FDL Peshawar, while payment was made to M/s Health Tech Quetta. The audit also raised objections over differences between supply orders and bills and the reported non-availability of required stock register entries, delivery challans and inspection reports.
The Health Department had maintained before the Departmental Accounts Committee (DAC) that M/s FDL was the manufacturing agency while M/s Health Tech was its authorized distributor, which supplied the medicines and received payment.
The audit, however, reported that some records and documents subsequently sought for verification were not provided.
Tareen directed the authorities concerned to produce the complete record relating to the audit para within 15 days.
Rs22.825m Drug Stock Audit Para Reviewed
The committee also examined an audit objection concerning Rs22.825 million worth of medicines reportedly unaccounted for at the central store.
According to the special audit, medicines of that value were found missing from the central store during fiscal year 2019-20, while relevant delivery challans and inspection committee reports were also not available in the record examined.
The Health Department, however, had disputed the audit observation before the DAC, maintaining that no medicines had gone missing from the central store.
According to the audit, subsequent examination of the available record identified discrepancies between opening and closing balances in the stock register and also flagged certain entries as having been made retrospectively.
Suspending Employees Alone Not Sufficient: Tareen
The PAC chairman said suspending employees alone was not sufficient and called for responsibility to be determined and action taken in accordance with law where warranted.
Committee members Fazal Qadir Mandokhail, Muhammad Khan Lehri, Safia Fazal, Rehmat Saleh Baloch and Wali Muhammad Noorzai also expressed concern over the lack of progress, noting that it was the committee’s fourth meeting on the audit paras and that the department had previously been given several opportunities, including an extension in September 2025.
Tareen said the PAC’s statutory oversight role was intended to ensure transparency, accountability and financial discipline in the use of public resources. He also voiced concern over the Health Department’s performance, saying that despite expenditure running into billions of rupees, the desired results were not being achieved.
The chairman also expressed concern over reports that some suspended employees were allegedly continuing to attend offices. He said the Chief Secretary Balochistan would be informed in writing, while the matter would also be brought before the Provincial Assembly.
Health Department Given Final 15 Days to Submit Record
At the conclusion of the meeting, the Health Department was given 15 days to submit the complete record, explanations and supporting documents relating to both audit paras to the PAC.
Balochistan Assembly Secretary Tahir Shah Kakar, Director General Audit Shuja Ali, Health Department Special Secretary Shahaik Baloch, PAC Special Secretary Siraj Lehri, Additional Secretary Law Saeed Iqbal, Civil Hospital Quetta Medical Superintendent Dr Hadi, DG Health Balochistan Dr Amin and other officials attended the meeting.



1 Comment
Pingback: Youth Role Crucial in Fight Against Corruption: NAB Balochistan - Daily 6AM