By Hammad Gillani
In Pakistan, whenever the question of new provinces comes up, our politicians make speeches, announce plans and promise to look into the matter. For a few days, the debate makes headlines. Then everything goes quiet. The people who have been demanding better administration return to their everyday problems, while those in power move on to other political matters. This reminds me of an interesting story from Brazil. In 1985, a Brazilian politician named Siqueira Campos was on a hunger strike. By the fourth day, he had become weak. His doctor brought him a plate of lentils, one of his favourite foods, but Campos politely refused to eat. He was protesting for the creation of a separate state in northern Goiás, an area that had long been ignored by the provincial government. People there believed that their region was not receiving enough attention or resources. They wanted a government closer to them, one that could better understand their needs. Their demand faced political and financial objections, but they continued their struggle. Three years later, Brazil’s 1988 Constitution created a new state called Tocantins. Campos became its first governor in 1989. Later studies suggested that the division brought economic benefits to the region.
Whenever I think about this story, I wonder why Pakistan has found it so difficult to seriously discuss the creation of new provinces. Our country has a growing population, and many areas still lack basic facilities. Yet most important decisions are made in a few major cities. People living in distant districts often feel that their problems receive little attention. Take southern Punjab, for example. A farmer there is concerned about irrigation water, expensive fertilisers, the cost of farming and getting a fair price for his crops. Better canals, roads and markets could make a real difference to his life. Now consider a factory worker in Karachi. His concerns are different. He needs reliable electricity, water, transport and job security. Both people want a better life, but their problems cannot always be solved through the same policies. Punjab alone had nearly 128 million people according to the 2023 census. Managing such a large population from Lahore is not an easy task. While development projects in Lahore may be necessary, people in Rajanpur, Bahawalpur and other distant areas have their own needs.
For a family in Rajanpur, a properly functioning hospital may be far more important than another expensive development project in the provincial capital. Balochistan faces a different situation. Its population is smaller, but the province covers a huge area. In many places, people must travel long distances to reach hospitals, schools and government offices. Such problems demand solutions based on local conditions. This is why I believe Pakistan needs more provinces. Not because creating a new province will solve every problem overnight, but because smaller administrative units may allow governments to pay greater attention to the people they serve. Unfortunately, our political debate usually goes in another direction. Whenever new provinces are discussed, the first questions seem to be about political power. Which party will benefit? Who will become chief minister? Which political family will lose its influence? Somehow, the ordinary citizen disappears from the discussion.
In May 2012, the Punjab Assembly passed resolutions supporting South Punjab and Bahawalpur as separate provinces. The Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Assembly has also supported the demand for a Hazara province. Years have passed, governments have changed and promises have been repeated. But the people are still waiting. Of course, dividing a province is not a simple matter. People have emotional connections with their language, culture, history and land. The concerns expressed over proposals to divide Sindh, for instance, should not be ignored. Those supporting new provinces must explain how people’s identity, rights and resources will be protected. At the same time, those opposing such proposals should explain how they intend to improve the lives of people living in neglected areas. Simply saying yes or no is not enough. Pakistan’s Constitution provides a clear procedure. Under Article 239, a constitutional amendment requires a two-thirds majority in both houses of parliament. Changing a province’s boundaries also requires approval by a two-thirds majority of the concerned provincial assembly.
A referendum may help understand public opinion, but it cannot replace these constitutional requirements. Political agreement and public trust are both necessary. Then comes the question of money. New provinces will need assemblies, offices and administrative staff. There will also be questions about the distribution of funds, water, government property and existing debts. These matters must be settled carefully. But do we really need expensive government buildings, large official residences and new fleets of vehicles from the very beginning? Why not use existing buildings and spend the available money on hospitals, schools, roads and clean drinking water? After all, these are the very problems that have encouraged people to demand new provinces.
There is another matter we should not forget. Creating more provinces will achieve little if power remains limited to the new provincial capitals. Article 140A of the Constitution calls for elected local governments to receive political, administrative and financial powers. Yet our political leaders often demand more authority from Islamabad while remaining unwilling to share their own powers with district and local governments. This attitude must change. I support new provinces where there is a genuine administrative need and public support. However, I also believe that local governments must be strengthened. Otherwise, people may simply find themselves travelling to a new provincial capital instead of the old one.
The purpose of creating new provinces should not be to produce more ministers, governors or government offices. It should be to make life easier for ordinary citizens. The people of Tocantins eventually received a government closer to their region. In Pakistan, people are still asking for something similar: a government that listens to them and understands their problems. Perhaps one day we will have more provinces. But the real question is whether our political leaders are ready to share power, or whether they simply want more places from which to exercise it. (The writer is a social activist and opinion writer who on climate change, social issues and public rights. the website is www.hammadgillani.com)


