Imran Khan’s hospital transfer, the memory of Nawaz Sharif’s London departure and speculation over a new political arrangement underline a larger question: can Pakistan place Parliament, Constitution and public consent at the centre of its political future?
By Syed Anwar Shah
Pakistan’s political climate appears to be showing signs of an unexpected thaw. After years of confrontation, mistrust and institutional tension, channels of communication among political forces seem to be reopening. If this shift develops into genuine dialogue rather than another temporary tactical accommodation, it could offer the country a rare opportunity to move away from perpetual political conflict.
That opportunity, however, comes with questions.
The Supreme Court’s decision concerning former prime minister Imran Khan’s health and medical treatment has acquired significance beyond the immediate issue of healthcare. The reported direction regarding his transfer to Shifa International has naturally drawn attention to his right to appropriate medical treatment, but it has also generated political debate about what, if anything, the development could mean for the wider political landscape.
The first principle should be straightforward: every prisoner is entitled to appropriate medical care, irrespective of political identity or status. Health should neither become an instrument of political punishment nor a privilege determined by political influence.
At the same time, major developments involving the country’s most prominent political figures inevitably generate speculation. The responsible response is not to turn speculation into fact, but to demand sufficient transparency so that speculation does not fill an information vacuum.
Questions being raised about whether Imran Khan’s medical situation could become connected to a broader political accommodation should therefore be treated precisely as questions — not established facts. If no such arrangement exists, clarity from the government and relevant institutions would help dispel unnecessary suspicion. If political negotiations are taking place, they should ultimately remain within constitutional and democratic boundaries.
Pakistan’s own recent history explains why such concerns emerge so quickly.
In 2019, former prime minister Nawaz Sharif’s deteriorating health became a major political and legal issue. After his platelet count fell sharply, he was moved from prison to hospital and eventually sought permission to travel abroad for treatment. The government initially sought a substantial indemnity bond as a condition for his departure, a demand challenged by the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz. The matter reached the Lahore High Court, which subsequently allowed him to travel abroad for medical treatment subject to legal undertakings.
What followed became part of Pakistan’s political history. London was no longer viewed simply as the place where Nawaz Sharif was receiving treatment. Over subsequent years, meetings involving senior political figures repeatedly took place there, giving rise to the perception that significant conversations about Pakistan’s political direction were occurring thousands of kilometres away from the country itself.
That does not mean every meeting in London represented a secret political arrangement. It would be irresponsible to present it that way. But it does raise a legitimate democratic question:
Should decisions shaping Pakistan’s political future be centered in London — or in Pakistan’s Parliament, constitutional institutions and electorate?
That question is equally relevant today.
Health Must Not Become Political Engineering
Imran Khan’s circumstances are not identical to Nawaz Sharif’s, and the two cases should not be artificially equated. Each has its own legal, medical and political context.
Yet both offer the same broader lesson: health, law and politics should never become so entangled that citizens are left guessing about the real purpose of major decisions.
A political leader’s illness must never be exploited for revenge. Equally, medical treatment should not become a vehicle for engineering political outcomes. Decisions about treatment should be based on medical necessity and law; political questions should be resolved through political and constitutional processes.
If negotiations are under way between the government and opposition, that in itself should not be considered undesirable. Pakistan needs political dialogue. Years of zero-sum confrontation have weakened institutions, damaged economic confidence and deepened political polarization.
But dialogue and political engineering are two very different things.
Dialogue allows political forces to negotiate openly within constitutional limits. Political engineering attempts to predetermine outcomes and then construct a process around them.
Pakistan needs the former, not the latter.
Is a Larger Political Reset Being Considered?
The more consequential question is whether Pakistan is approaching merely another change in political alignments or something deeper involving its constitutional, administrative or political structure.
There has been periodic debate over new provinces, administrative units, resource distribution, electoral reforms, provincial autonomy and the respective powers of state institutions. These are legitimate subjects for national discussion.
Any fundamental restructuring of Pakistan’s federation would affect millions of citizens and future generations. Questions involving provincial boundaries, representation, resources, electoral arrangements and institutional authority cannot legitimately belong to one party, one government, one personality or one institution.
They require broad public consent.
That is where Parliament should assume its proper role.
Pakistan’s elected representatives — government and opposition alike — should be able to debate the country’s future without coercion, intimidation or predetermined conclusions. A political settlement created by forcing participants towards a particular outcome may produce temporary stability, but it is unlikely to create lasting legitimacy.
Could a Constituent Process Be Considered?
If Pakistan’s political forces genuinely conclude that the country requires a fundamental constitutional reset rather than limited reforms, one option worthy of democratic debate could be a freely elected constituent assembly with a clearly defined mandate.
Such an idea should not be treated casually. Pakistan already has a Constitution, and any departure from the existing constitutional framework would carry profound legal and political implications. The preferred route for reform should therefore remain the mechanisms provided by the Constitution itself.
Nevertheless, if an overwhelming national consensus were ever to emerge around a broader constituent process, its legitimacy could come only from free elections, public participation and acceptance across the federation — never from an arrangement devised by a limited group of political or institutional actors.
Such a body, if constitutionally and democratically established, could deliberate on questions including federal relations, administrative units, resource distribution, electoral reform and institutional powers.
But the sequence matters: public consent must come before structural change, not after it.
Credible Elections Are the Starting Point
No political reset can command lasting legitimacy if citizens do not trust the electoral process that produces it.
Restoring confidence in elections must therefore be central to any serious attempt at national reconciliation.
If political forces agree that a neutral transitional arrangement is required before fresh elections, any such mechanism must remain firmly within constitutional limits, enjoy broad political acceptance and have a narrowly defined purpose: creating conditions in which citizens can choose their representatives freely.
A caretaker or transitional administration should not be used to redesign the state, make irreversible long-term political decisions or favor particular actors. Its credibility would depend precisely on its restraint and neutrality.
Pakistan does not need another arrangement whose legitimacy becomes disputed before it has even begun.
Pakistan has experienced too many episodes in which illness became a political crisis, courts became extensions of political conflict, exile became an alternative political headquarters and overseas meetings appeared more consequential than parliamentary debate.
That cycle should end.
Whether the venue is London, Lahore, Adiala or Islamabad, the ultimate authority over Pakistan’s political future must rest with its Constitution, representative institutions and people.
If the current political atmosphere is genuinely becoming less confrontational, political leaders should use the moment to build national reconciliation rather than another engineered arrangement.
Imran Khan, Nawaz Sharif or any other individual should neither become the sole axis of Pakistan’s political system nor the instrument through which that system is redesigned.
The principle should be simple: whatever political decision is made should emerge through an open constitutional process; whatever change is proposed should carry public consent; and whatever future political map is envisioned should be debated in Pakistan, by Pakistanis, through institutions accountable to them.
Pakistan has reached such crossroads before and repeatedly paid a price when short-term political calculations prevailed over durable constitutional solutions.
If political leaders learn from the past, restore Parliament as the principal arena of political decision-making, protect judicial independence, ensure credible elections and recognize citizens as the ultimate source of democratic authority, today’s uncertainty could become the beginning of a more stable political era.
The real question, therefore, is larger than the fate of any one political leader.
Will Pakistan’s political future finally be decided in Pakistan — transparently, constitutionally and by its people?
The writer is associated with journalism and media and is Chief Editor of daily Nawey Zawand.


