Freedom must be expanded, not restricted by fear
By Syed Anwar Shah
A recent reception hosted by Malik Anwar Saleem Kasi in honour of distinguished writer, researcher and intellectual Noor Khan Muhammad Hasni, following the conferment of the Tamgha-e-Imtiaz on him by the Government of Pakistan, unexpectedly developed into a wider debate about knowledge, artificial intelligence, generational change and freedom.
Munir Badini, Dostain Jamaldini, Agha Gul, Malik Anwar Saleem Kasi, Dr Shireen Khan, Saleh Muhammad Karkar, Abdul Mateen Akhundzada and other speakers reflected on the challenges facing the younger generation, the role of senior intellectuals and the demands of a rapidly changing technological age. Kasi also announced a special award for Hasni in recognition of his intellectual and literary contributions.
One argument emerging from the discussion was that younger people, equipped with modern technology and greater access to information, are better positioned to meet contemporary challenges. There is merit in recognising their technological advantage, but it would be a mistake to equate access to information with intellectual superiority.
Artificial intelligence has dramatically changed how people obtain and process information, but AI did not create human knowledge. It largely works with knowledge accumulated through generations of human research, observation, experimentation and creativity. The younger generation may possess technological speed and access; older generations bring experience, historical memory and intellectual perspective. Society needs both.
This distinction is increasingly important because information is not the same as knowledge, and knowledge is not the same as wisdom. Technology can provide answers within seconds, but it cannot remove the need for critical thinking, intellectual training, ethical judgment and an understanding of consequences. An abundance of information without such grounding can produce confidence without depth.
The history of technology offers the same lesson. Nuclear science can generate energy and support medicine, yet it can also produce weapons capable of catastrophic destruction. The problem is not technology alone, but how human beings choose to use it. The same applies to AI: it can advance education, science and productivity, but without responsibility and accountability it can also become a means of misinformation, manipulation and concentration of power.
Nor should humanity become so dependent on digital systems that traditional methods of preserving knowledge are neglected. Wars, technological failures or major crises can disrupt digital infrastructure. Books, libraries, archives, writing and human memory therefore remain essential. Civilizations survive not simply by producing knowledge, but by preserving and transmitting it.
Perhaps the most important point raised at the gathering came from Munir Badini: fear has caused us to restrict our own freedom.
This takes the discussion beyond AI and generational differences. Societies cannot develop intellectually when people are afraid to ask questions, challenge assumptions or seek accountability. Freedom is not merely the right to live according to personal choice; it includes the ability to think, research, disagree and question those who exercise power — responsibly and within the law.
A society that wants innovation cannot discourage questioning. A society that celebrates knowledge cannot fear independent thought.
The real debate, therefore, should not be whether the younger generation is superior to the older one. The challenge is to bring their strengths together. Young people need technological competence as well as history, literature, philosophy, critical thinking and the accumulated experience of earlier generations. Senior intellectuals, in turn, must engage with new technologies and understand the rapidly changing world in which younger people live.
Despite unprecedented access to information, the greatest deficit facing the future may not be a shortage of information at all. It may be a shortage of intellectual depth, training, ethical judgment and the courage to think independently.
The future will consequently be shaped neither by AI alone nor by books alone, neither by the young alone nor by the old. It will be shaped by people capable of combining technology with wisdom, information with judgment, experience with innovation, and knowledge with freedom.
That is why freedom should not be restricted because of fear. It should be responsibly expanded. A society driven by fear may survive for a time, but a society built on knowledge, training, freedom and courage acquires something far more enduring: the ability to shape its own future.


