From disturbing cases in Chaman to exchange marriages in Zhob, poverty, harmful customs and weak enforcement threaten girls’ education, health and fundamental rights
| By M. Rafiq Mandokhail |
Childhood is meant for learning, growth and opportunity, not marriage, motherhood or decisions imposed by others. Yet in parts of Balochistan, poverty, deeply rooted traditions and social pressures continue to place young girls at risk of early marriage, depriving them of education, personal freedom and the opportunity to determine their own futures.
A disturbing case reported in Chaman in September 2026 has brought this issue into sharp focus. Allegations involving the marriage of a three-year-old girl to a 60-year-old man, a reported payment of Rs. 2.5 million under the traditional Walwar system, and the alleged murder of a 15-year-old girl from the same family raise serious concerns about child protection and accountability.
According to the girls’ father, Abdul Baqi, financial hardship led him to arrange his daughter Shukria Bibi’s marriage in exchange for Rs. 2.5 million. He further claimed that subsequent family disputes involved proposals to marry off his younger daughters and ultimately resulted in Shukria Bibi’s killing. These serious allegations demand an independent investigation, with the facts and any criminal responsibility established through due legal process.
The tragedy raises a fundamental question: How can a child too young to understand marriage be expected to consent to a lifelong commitment?
The problem is not confined to Chaman. In Zhob, the traditional exchange-marriage practice known as Wata Satta has also placed young girls under considerable family and social pressure.
One young woman, identified under the pseudonym Gul Sema, described how an exchange-marriage arrangement made when she was only five years old affected her childhood, education and emotional well-being. At 18, she sought legal relief to escape the arrangement that had overshadowed her life for more than a decade.
Other accounts from Zhob describe girls being promised in marriage at an early age, with family elders making decisions without consulting those most directly affected.
These experiences expose a troubling reality: decisions made during childhood can have consequences extending far into adulthood.
The impact on education is particularly concerning. A 2022 study examining school dropout factors in Kech district identified child marriage among the reasons associated with students leaving secondary education. Although the study’s limited sample does not establish the province-wide scale of the problem, its findings reinforce concerns about the relationship between early marriage and interrupted schooling.
Health consequences are equally serious. Gynecologist Dr. Shazia Khpalwak has warned that early marriage and adolescent pregnancy can expose girls to psychological distress, inadequate maternal healthcare and complications during pregnancy and childbirth. These include excessive bleeding, pregnancy-related hypertension, prolonged labor, premature delivery and risks to newborns.
For girls who lack access to timely medical care, these dangers can become even more severe.
The legal framework offers an important basis for protection. The Balochistan Child Marriages Restraint Act, 2025, establishes 18 as the minimum marriage age and provides penalties for violations. According to lawyer Muhammad Naeem, adults involved in contracting, arranging or facilitating prohibited child marriages may face imprisonment and financial penalties. The law also imposes responsibilities on marriage registrars and other relevant officials.
Importantly, the legislation allows individuals and organizations beyond a child’s immediate family to report suspected violations, potentially providing protection where parents or guardians are themselves involved.
Judicial interpretations have also addressed religious objections to minimum marriage-age legislation. The Federal Shariat Court has held that the state may prescribe a minimum marriage age without violating Islamic principles, emphasizing the importance of education. The Islamabad High Court has likewise addressed the legal capacity and consent of minors in marriage.
These rulings provide an important response to arguments that child marriage restrictions necessarily conflict with religious teachings.
However, the central challenge is not simply the absence of legislation, but whether existing protections are effectively implemented.
Malik Ehsan-ul-Haq Mandokhail, Deputy Director of the Social Welfare Department, has acknowledged serious shortcomings in child protection arrangements, including the limited functioning of district-level coordination mechanisms. Other departmental officials have pointed to inadequate monitoring, particularly in rural communities where early marriage practices reportedly persist.
Such accounts suggest a significant gap between legal commitments and institutional performance.
Professor Abdul Rehman Amin Mandokhail has rightly emphasized that legislation alone cannot eliminate child marriage. Families need awareness, girls require safe access to education, and economically vulnerable households must have opportunities that reduce their dependence on harmful customary arrangements.
Community elders, religious scholars, teachers, healthcare professionals and civil society organizations all have an important role in changing attitudes. Traditions deserve respect, but no custom should justify denying children their safety, dignity or fundamental rights.
The provincial government must strengthen district child protection committees, ensure proper marriage registration and age verification, investigate reported violations, and make protection and legal assistance accessible to vulnerable girls. Equally essential are continued schooling, community awareness and targeted economic support for disadvantaged families.
Enforcement must be fair, transparent and consistent. Protecting children should never depend on their family’s influence, financial position or ability to attract public attention.
The experiences reported from Chaman and Zhob should serve as a warning that child marriage is not merely a private family matter. It is a public concern involving education, healthcare, justice, social welfare and the responsibility of the state.
Balochistan’s progress cannot be measured by development projects and legislation alone while girls remain vulnerable to decisions that deny them control over their futures.
The real test of society’s commitment to its children is whether it protects their right to learn, grow and make informed choices when they reach adulthood.
A girl’s future must be shaped by her abilities, aspirations and opportunities—not poverty, coercion or outdated customs. Childhood belongs in classrooms and playgrounds, not in marriage contracts.


