QUETTA |The Balochistan High Court has dismissed MNA Adil Khan Bazai’s petition challenging the withdrawal of his police security, ruling that security provided in the past does not create a specific legal right to its permanent continuation.
Court declines to intervene in withdrawal of seven police personnel; says MNA may seek fresh threat assessment if facing a genuine security risk
A two-member bench comprising Chief Justice Muhammad Kamran Khan Mulakhail and Justice Muhammad Najmuddin Mengal observed that no material had been placed before the court establishing a legal obligation to continue deploying seven police personnel for the petitioner irrespective of the prevailing security assessment.
Bazai had referred to alleged threats and the registration of FIR No. 64/2026. The court, however, noted that no material had been presented to demonstrate mala fide action, disregard of any mandatory legal requirement or unlawful exercise of authority by the competent officials.
The bench observed that threat perception and security requirements are dynamic matters based on intelligence inputs and protective considerations and are primarily for the competent administrative and security authorities to assess.
It held that in the absence of concrete evidence of discrimination, mala fide, illegality or manifest arbitrariness, the court would refrain from interfering under Article 199 of the Constitution in matters falling within the domain of competent security authorities.
The court, however, clarified that if Bazai apprehends a genuine threat to his life or safety, he may approach the competent authorities with relevant material for a fresh threat assessment. The authorities would then consider the matter objectively in accordance with law, applicable policy and the prevailing security situation.
The bench also referred to an earlier judgment in Constitutional Petition No. 1352 of 2019, decided on November 29, 2021, which laid down a mechanism for politicians and other individuals facing genuine security threats to approach the relevant deputy commissioners and divisional commissioners for consideration by the District Intelligence Coordination Committee and Divisional Threat Assessment Committee.
The court noted that the Balochistan Home Department subsequently issued standard operating procedures on December 22, 2023, providing a framework for threat assessment and the engagement of registered private security companies in appropriate cases.
Concluding that the nature and extent of security required should initially be determined by the competent authorities under the applicable legal and administrative framework, the bench dismissed Bazai’s petition as devoid of merit, with no order as to costs.


